The Right to Repair and Our Future

May 1, 2022

I stay away from political topics, but there’s one exception falling within tech politics that I am passionate about. For me, it’s a basic human right to have the Right to Repair. It is the ability to fix any equipment or possession we own with the proper cooperation of the manufacturer. Sometimes manufacturers go out of business, or these days supply chain issues may cause shortages of parts. If a piece of equipment (hardware or software) malfunctions, it is crucial to have the needed maintenance documentation so that someone has the ability to fix the problem. Besides documentation—which is like a cookbook on how to maintain and fix something—it is beneficial to have the ingredients as well: parts must be available on the open market.

In certain cases of supply issues, simply having a good enough maintenance manual could help with 3D-printing a part at a makerspace. Some companies (most notably Apple) not only withhold engineering documentation required for repair from the public, but also go out of their way to cause intentional shortages of certain parts on the open market. Apple blackmails the manufacturers of specific chips: if the chip appears on the open market, Apple will terminate the contract. As a result, even though the chip in question is not the essential brain of an Apple laptop motherboard, it can make certain repairs completely impossible.

All I want is this: if your kid water-damages your iPad or the screen cracks, you should have the choice to either go to the Genius Bar or choose a 3rd-party repair shop. If you ask me, I would rather go to Louis Rossmann’s repair shop in NY—or even mail in the device—because he can likely fix it in a couple of days for a lower price than the Genius Bar. If you watch Louis’s YouTube channel, it seems that the quality of his work can also be better and more thorough than Apple’s repair shops. As an added bonus, you won’t experience an unnecessary round trip to a central repair location and won’t lose your data in case you haven’t backed it up (a backup might not even be possible in the case of certain malfunctions). Having the choice of 3rd-party repair shops would be beneficial for everyone, even for those who prefer the Genius Bar, because ultimately it would lower repair prices and increase quality. Why are Tesla repair prices astronomical while repair wait times are laughably outrageous? Why can’t someone just go to a 3rd-party repair shop of their choice when the certified shop might be hours away? Right to Repair laws could help with these problems.

It’s not a coincidence that Rich Rebuilds’s Electrified Garage is located in New Hampshire. There are stronger Right to Repair laws there, so Tesla was forced to provide a certain level of documentation. Of course, there’s still a lot of room for improvement; that’s why it’s important to keep pushing the Right to Repair movement forward and stand up. Unfortunately, most of the largest car manufacturers are against Right to Repair, and they put millions of dollars of lobbying pressure into legislation. Fortunately, Joe Biden understood the importance of Right to Repair and resisted the gigantic financial pressure and relentless lobbying. Do not get scared just because these car manufacturers use security-through-obscurity practices and claim security scares. Rather, cars need true cryptographic security solutions along with Right to Repair, not FUD (Fear, Uncertainty, Disorientation / Disinformation) against repair, and companies should not sustain and protect weak security practices.

The Right to Repair has a much broader importance. For example, it is an essential part of sustainability. Sustainability’s three big principles are, in priority order:

  1. Reduce
  2. Reuse
  3. Recycle

So no matter how certain “green” companies may recycle electronics or use recycled materials (or have zero-emission offices), it is more important to extend the lifetime of a device as long as possible, and to repair it so its lifecycle can be extended. The higher-priority Reduce and Reuse principles are supported by that. Recycling comes only after that, and we should avoid throwing out a device at all costs. Unfortunately, this would make a dent in sales numbers, since customers wouldn’t run to the Apple Store for a brand-new phone as often.

Recently, I bought a Google Pixel 6 phone for my wife for Christmas because although her Pixel 3 was perfectly fine, it was 3 years old and the software support was coming close to EOL (End of Life). Fortunately, these days Samsung raised the bar with four major Android version updates and five years of support, and Google is trying to follow suit. One reason I decided on the Pixel 6 was its longer software support period compared to the Pixel 3, as well as having stock Android without bloatware. In the future—and even now—software support periods could be more important than hardware obsolescence. Since 3rd-party repair is not as constrained for Android phones, I could easily have the Pixel 3’s battery replaced for only about $70.

Companies operate using various techniques that translate to planned obsolescence. A famous example is the iPhone Batterygate, where Apple secretly started to throttle the performance and battery handling of older phones. That indirectly pushed users who were reluctant to upgrade toward brand-new phones. Apple ended up settling a class-action lawsuit over this and had to pay out $113 million, and other lawsuits are also ongoing, like one in Portugal about iPhone 6 planned obsolescence (see also this video) or the iOS 14 battery drain bug - also planned obsolescence. Apple relentlessly tries to bully its users: first contemplating not forcing you to upgrade to iOS 15 from iOS 14, but of course that would be bad for sales, so the upgrade became mandatory after all. Is this really what we want in the future? I have a feeling the average Apple customer doesn’t even know about this; they just live in blissful ignorance because they can afford it right now. But this can come back to bite us in the future.

Bullying users into an upgrade is only one piece of the puzzle. Another piece is “taking care” of their old devices. Apple tries to prevent used devices from hitting the secondhand market, because that would poach potential customers too. The aim is to make sure all these devices get destroyed—even if they could have been saved. It’s disgustingly greedy corporate behavior that is completely contrary to sustainability, all while bathing in the false green light of a futuristic headquarters’ zero emissions. The recycling center, which saved phones from becoming electronic waste, can be looked at as a sustainability hero, and it is ugly corporate behavior to forcibly dismantle salvageable equipment. I mentioned earlier that reuse is a higher priority than recycling.

Apple started a 3rd-party repair program to soothe and calm down pro-Right to Repair legislative momentum and pretend that things are on the right track. Many people—including Louis Rossmann—analyzed the program and warned that it would be too costly and too limited for an entrepreneur: it requires tens of thousands of dollars to purchase special equipment and training, and the possible repairs covered have profit margins that are far too low. As a result, it is a failure for independent repair shops. At the same time, newer iPhones keep blocking repair with more vengeance than ever. So don’t be fooled.

Since I started writing this blog post, several notable events—both positive and negative—have happened in the Right to Repair space. Both Samsung and Google made it easier to service their mobile devices by teaming up with iFixit for self repair solutions. Although all modern phone and tablet repairability scores are pretty awful, manufacturers tend to follow Apple’s bad practices like gluing in the battery for no reason. But at least these self-service repair programs point in a good direction.

Recent news is that Apple announced a self service program, however one problem with that is the same as with their 3rd party repair program. Namely: Apple, which is looked at as a noble knight of security and privacy—and which supposedly rises above Android and goes as far as refusing to help the government unlock terrorists’ iPhones—requires excruciating details about every repaired device and owner, such as IMEI numbers. The question arises: is this really the champion of our privacy?

Let’s move on from Apple and start to think about whether we’ll really own our devices in the future. For example, Elon Musk can decide to turn off certain features (like Supercharger capability or FSD—Full Self-Driving) remotely over the air on any Tesla at will, at any time. When Rich Rebuilds’ repaired Tesla’s supercharging capability was canceled remotely, it felt like retaliation for criticism. Will we basically just be renters of our standard equipment? Is this what we want?

Let me turn now to fitness machines, which are the main targets of my favorite project (Track My Indoor Workout). You can buy smart spin bikes or treadmills at relatively affordable prices, but they almost always come with a bundled subscription service to the manufacturer’s endorsed fitness portal. That mostly means an iFit subscription, or another example is Peloton’s subscription. People buy these devices, but what happens once the prepaid subscription included in the purchase ends after—say—a year? Users may be reluctant to pay for such a subscription, accelerating a trend of machines becoming coat racks.

Sometimes the fitness equipment has a mode where the owner can use it without the subscription. The manufacturer does not want to make such a mode easily available, and sometimes users even have to tinker just to freely use a $4,000 piece of equipment! That is what happened in the case of NordicTrack’s X32i (which normally comes with the $39/month iFit). The vendor had the audacity to lock out owners who weren’t put up with iFit subscription. Staying with treadmills, another story is the Peloton Tread+, which is even more expensive—if that’s even possible: just shy of $5,000. The Tread+ Treadmill had the “Just Run” mode, allowing owners to get by without the $39/month Peloton subscription. So, citing safety reasons, Peloton cut that feature, which caused a major backlash.

To align with Track My Indoor Workout’s mission, I’ll try to support iFit devices, but right now I’m only exploring possibilities for that.

Finally, I’d like to mention a few more negative news items regarding repair. Onewheel’s manufacturer goes out of its way to block any repair attempts: for example, disconnecting the battery bricks the controller circuit. Users with any problem have to ship their board to a single repair center in the US, even from the other side of the world! Not to mention the regression of models in terms of durability and repairability. This is what happens when a company is controlled by overly greedy and short-sighted investors. And lately, Chevy announced that after 5 years of manufacturing, it will stop servicing Chevy Spark EV vehicles. If that’s not bad enough, it seems that they won’t provide battery replacements anymore. This can turn away buyers who were looking to buy EVs. Honda also started to crack down and attack 3D printable parts on maker websites. This is even more sinister given that parts may not be available due to supply chain issues, and then you cannot even print them for yourself? The list goes on and on; the fight for Right to Repair needs to prevail.

The most powerful influence customers can have is voting with their wallets. Do not buy devices that are manufactured by bad Right to Repair actors. Do not buy Onewheel, and do not waste your money paying extra for unrepairable Apple devices. Buy used and renewed devices whenever possible. Do not buy fancy, overpriced fitness machines that may lock you out. Try to weed out and avoid buying any equipment that may lock you out or remove features (judging by the manufacturer’s tendencies and demeanor).

Comments loading...